Unfortunately, with the ever-growing interest in antique scientific instruments, more and more mass-produced fakes and reproductions are flooding the market. This can be a costly lesson for unsuspecting buyers, as many of these instruments can look quite authentic.

Some internet auction sites in particular have many instruments advertised as genuine pieces. In fairness, many sellers genuinely believe the item is authentic, but there are also unscrupulous sellers who knowingly try to pass off fakes as real antiques.

I wish to make it clear that I do not have a problem with people selling reproductions—as long as they are clearly described as such to any prospective buyer.

Indeed, some of the instruments are quite decorative and can display well in certain situations, but they do not represent any of the real characteristics of a genuine antique instrument.

So how does one distinguish a fake from the real thing?

Unfortunately, there is no substitute for experience and knowledge. But those of us with some expertise can hopefully guide newcomers to this field of collecting.

To this end, I have created this page as a visual reference point for those who may not yet be familiar with some of the replicas currently in circulation—many of which are cheap imports from Asia.

I come across many reproductions in the course of my collecting activities and decided it may benefit others if I shared photos of these items, mainly to inform.

I'm not seeking to prevent people from buying reproductions if that's their intention—but hopefully I can help those looking for authentic items avoid the disappointment of unknowingly buying a fake.

In running this website, I receive many requests for information and valuations of specific instruments. I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve had to tell people that their 'antique' compass or telescope is, in fact, a modern replica from India.

SOME TIPS

Compasses and telescopes are the most commonly reproduced instruments and often carry well-known maker names—particularly Stanley. More recently, respected names such as Dollond, Ross, Ottway, and Hughes are also being copied.

Reproduction compasses often have crudely made needles with a red or blue tip to indicate North. Reproduction telescopes frequently feature leather cladding with very loose stitching compared to authentic examples. Also, be cautious of instruments with an 'antique patina'—this is often an artificially applied finish.

Of course, there are many other factors to consider when evaluating an instrument. It’s difficult to list them all, so please review the examples below to get a feel for the common traits of reproductions. The manufacturers of these replicas are constantly expanding their range and improving their aesthetic quality, so stay vigilant!

SOME PHOTO EXAMPLES

Below are some examples of reproduction instruments. I’ll continue adding to this gallery as I encounter new types. I hope this proves useful for anyone interested in collecting scientific instruments. If you're unsure about the authenticity of an item you're considering, feel free to contact me—I'm happy to help.